Subscribe
Sign up to our monthly e-mail about the latest and greatest places for food, wine art and history
A Former Prohibition-Era Speakeasy Steeped in Literary History
& why it made the Carpe City list
Edna St. Vincent Millay, the first woman to win the Pulitzer for poetry and a noted radical-about-town would occasionally tend the bar, which was diagonally across the street from her house (at 75 ½ Bedford Street, said to be the narrowest house in the Village). If Lee Chumley was away, Millay’s sister Norma reported that Millay would invite her friends to the bar for free drinks!
It is said that the term “86’d,” meaning to be run out of someplace, originated at Chumley’s during prohibition. The owner, Lee Chumley, had an understanding with the police, and so got advanced notice of raids. Bartenders would shout “86!” as code to the customers that they should head out to avoid arrest.
There were many other getaway options – the former Chumley’s building had a back exit, a trap door, an alleyway through a bookcase, and a dumbwaiter to the second floor.
Chumley’s décor was inspired by their history: the faces and book jackets of the writers who frequented Chumley’s busy the walls. In the archway window there was a row of teacups, hearkening to prohibition, when patrons would drink their “tea” out of porcelain tea cups!
Sign up to our monthly e-mail about the latest and greatest places for food, wine art and history